![jane eyre movie length jane eyre movie length](https://s2982.pcdn.co/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/jane_eyre_red-room.jpg)
McCarthy doesn’t portray Rochester's mercurial personality, instead playing him like a middle-class TV sitcom dad. I prefer Charlton Heston as far as pre-60s TV adaptations go. The Bad: I'm not a fan of Kevin McCarthy's take on Rochester. Katharine Bard was the first actress who attempted to capture Jane's independent spirit, doing better than even some film actresses in declaring herself Rochester's equal. This adaptation improved on the 1949 version, adding more interaction between Jane and Rochester and taking more language from the novel. I was, however, pleasantly surprised by how much this adaptation used direct quotes from the book. The Good: This is another truncated TV studio tape that omits Jane's childhood and her time with the Rivers family. Jane Eyre 1952, starring Katharine Bard as Jane and Kevin McCarthy as Mr. The 1949 may be a slight improvement on the '57 and '34, but that doesn’t mean the adaptation is a good one.
![jane eyre movie length jane eyre movie length](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/4UUeotTS4pY/hqdefault.jpg)
Most those adaptations fail to include St. Instead of declaring her equality and independence in the proposal scene, Jane cries, "Oh, do not make sport of me!" and observes, "I am only Jane Eyre." Like most pre-60s adaptations (the '34, '43, '52, and '57), this version does not include Jane's time with the Rivers family or St. Whereas the Jane of the novel is blunt, even "brusque," Sinclair's Jane never volunteers her opinion unless strong-armed by Rochester. The writing does little to help this portrayal. The Bad: The above being said, Mary Sinclair's Jane is too reserved and mild-mannered.
![jane eyre movie length jane eyre movie length](https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/S/pv-target-images/aa5dfa7241646d978ad691700469c6a45061a2db6d1e9697c0685e3842b86a1d._RI_.jpg)
Heston’s Rochester wants to break class and employment boundaries while Mary Sinclair's Jane cautiously reminds him of their existence. The writers characterize Rochester as more of an authority figure, and Jane is particularly aware of her status as a governess. This adaptation also pays more attention to the ways class/social status affect interactions between characters. Rochester's enigmatical personality in a short amount of time. Charlton Heston in particular does a credible job of delivering his lines and presenting Mr. While this studio set TV version isn't good or faithful by any stretch of the imagination, the characters are at least portrayed somewhat more accurately. The Good: This version really only gets bumped up a little because the 1957 was so disappointing.